Before Apple Custard was born, Flim pretended to be reformed, Applejack bought it, she fell in love, had a kid with him, and then found out he’s still been running scams behind her back. That’s when she starts demanding a divorce. Flim decides he’s not leaving quietly, and tries to demand custody of the child.

Flim wants to take custody of Apple Custard to raise her as part of the Flim Flam Bros. as a Flim Flam Sister, but Applejack also wants to take custody of Apple Custard but to raise her as part of the Apple family instead. Apple Custard is very scared and doesn’t know what to do.