MLP

1. Discord is Discord

2. Starlight was smart and actually won, she was literally convinced to give up her victory to start her life over.

3. Just like Starlight she actually won untill the tree-ex-machina happened. She isn’t done yet so she could still rise in the ranks.

4. Tirek was a force to be reckoned with but he quickly became less interesting the stronger he got.

5. Equestria’s most consistent villain. Her plans are usually enacted off-screen, which I tend to have a major problem with.

6. Was smart enough to plan ahead and protect the crystal heart but didn’t get enough screen time.

7. Probably has the best backstory out of all the villains, and that’s about it.

8. In my opinion, she was the most boring villain in the shows history. But maybe that’s due to her being the first.

9. Was literally a man-child who tried too hard to be funny. Had nearly no screen time. You know its bad when your sidekick was more intimidating that you.

EQG

1. Do I even need to explain why?

2. I actually sympathized with Wallflower. The memory stone was cool as well and tied into already established lore nicely.

3. Wouldn’t be this high if it wasn’t for her portrayal in EQG4. She is easily the most powerful and the most intimidating of the EQG villains.

4. Her plan made no sense but she was at least better than the three villains below her. By this point the whole magic demon gimmick had gotten stale.

5. Bad Villain, Plan made no sense. But it was somehow still fun to watch this madness.

6. Had a cool concept with the mirror but ended up being a very annoying character.

7. Literally Who? She just copied Juniper’s plan, and somehow ended up being even more annoying than even she was.